Sklar and Trachtenberg, PHP Cookbook (3rd ed., 2014)

Sklar and Trachtenberg’s PHP Cookbook is a difficult book to review; the book is clearly written with at least two different audiences in mind, and this means that parts of the book vary in sophistication and depth. On the one hand, the book is intended in part to complement Sklar’s (2004!) Learning PHP 5, to serve as a second book for PHP novices, to cover some of the many topics that book’s “PHP with training wheels” approach did not. On the other hand, the book is intended for readers who are familiar with the basics of the language who want to learn how to do things well in PHP.

For the beginner, for example, Chap. 6 begins with an introduction to functions, and Chap. 7 on objects likewise begins with a very gentle introduction to objects; Chap. 1 covers the basics of working with substrings, and Chap. 18 introduces some issues in PHP security. However, beginners might be better served by reading the relevant sections in Tatroe et al.’s 2013 Programming PHP. Both cover much of the same ground, but I find Programming‘s coverage to be clearer and in greater depth.

This book also does a lot of what it says on the tin by providing a reference for a lot of situations you might run into when programming PHP. Need to work with email? Drop in some regular expressions? Mess around with an object using array syntax? (Look at 4.25 for the latter– a nice trick.) I personally don’t spend all of my time in PHP, and it’s nice to have code snippets at hand when you need them.

More than these individual recipes, the value of the book to my mind lies in the sections for the programmer who realizes that there are different ways to tackle a particular problem in PHP. PHP comes with a heap of built-in functions (some of which are redundant); these functions are further complemented by libraries, packages, and software that extend and supplement the core of PHP. A lot of PHP programming is simply coming to terms with all of these competing ways to do things, and this is one of the strengths of the Cookbook. Sklar and Trachtenberg often tell you which function to use, and why (though some parts simply list different possibilities without much differentiation). To pick an example at random, (*rimshot*) they explain why the (built-in) mt_rand() function is better than the (built-in) rand() function for generating random numbers within a particular range. This is not something Programming PHP is always good at, actually, and its function reference simply lists all of the functions without explaining differences between them (php.net can often be helpful in this regard, too).

It limits the usefulness of the book, however, that you have to go digging for these sections, that you don’t know in advance whether the recipe you’re interested in is a brief or introductory discussion for the beginning user or a helpful guide through the PHP wilds. In some ways, this book is like the maps nature parks often give out to tourists: some parts only give you a vague idea, while other parts of the map can be a reliable guide to the terrain. Sklar and Trachtenberg’s PHP Cookbook can still help you to get around, but it’s a good idea to keep your wits about you, and to make use of other resources, as well.

Advertisements

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s